The cylinder extends and retracts fine. Now you want it to stop halfway. Looking at the selection table you see "two-position, five-port" and "three-position, five-port", and it is easy to read it this way: two-position handles extend and retract; three-position adds one extra stop.
That reading is wrong in one important respect.
A "position" is an air-path state of the valve - not a stopping position of the cylinder. One more position does not mean one more lock.
First, five ports does not mean five ports flowing at once
Count them properly: one supply port, two working ports to the cylinder, two exhaust ports.
Supply is usually marked P; working ports A and B. In numeric marking, 1 is normally supply, 2 and 4 are working ports, 3 and 5 are exhaust. The actual letters and connections follow the valve body marking and the circuit diagram for that model.
What the valve does is arrange supply and exhaust for the two sides of the cylinder. In one position, one side is supplied and the other exhausts. In the other position, the two are swapped, and the cylinder reverses.
Two-position means two such air-path states. Which state extends the cylinder depends on how the two working lines are connected - not on guessing from the port layout.
Three-position adds a centre state beyond those two. On the valve symbol, two or three adjacent boxes represent the positions; the lines and arrows inside show the connections.
The part that actually needs choosing: the centre position
Three-position five-port valves come as closed centre, exhaust centre and pressure centre. The "centre" refers to the valve being in the middle position - not to the piston stopping halfway.
Closed centre. The main ports are blocked, so air no longer flows normally in or out of either cylinder chamber. It can support some mid-stroke pause requirements, but air is compressible and a moving load has inertia. After the valve returns to centre the piston may still shift, and it will not necessarily stop where you wanted. Leakage in the valve, cylinder or fittings can also let it drift over time. Closing the air is not the same as accurate positioning or long-term holding.
Exhaust centre. Supply is blocked and both working ports open to exhaust, so both chambers can vent. Note that this is not "vent it and it stops safely". Once the original air support is reduced, a weight or a spring can push the piston. If a cylinder is holding a load vertically, closed centre and exhaust centre are not casually interchangeable.
Pressure centre. Supply feeds both working ports and exhaust is blocked. On an ordinary single-rod cylinder the effective area is smaller on the rod side. The same pressure acting on different areas produces different forces, so supplying both sides does not guarantee the piston stays put. "Pressure on both sides" is not proof that the cylinder is locked.
Working through a selection question
Assume a cylinder moving a horizontal slide, and you want it to hold partway when pause is pressed.
Before specifying "three-position five-port", establish two things.
Is this a brief pause, or must it stop at a precise position? The first still requires an assessment of stopping deviation and load. The second cannot be guaranteed by an ordinary three-position closed-centre valve and needs a positioning solution assessed separately.
Is movement permitted after power or air loss? If movement could injure someone or damage a workpiece, valve selection cannot be based on normal running alone - locking or other safety measures must be assessed by the equipment designer.
Different requirements lead to different solutions. Three-position is not "more advanced" than two-position - you need a particular air-path state.
Before ordering, confirm these
Photograph the complete model number and the circuit symbol on the old valve and confirm two-position or three-position. If three-position, confirm closed, exhaust or pressure centre.
Then check actuation type, voltage, port size, flow capacity, and the working and pilot pressure requirements.
Double solenoid is not the same as three-position, and a port that fits is not proof of interchangeability.
If the motion is simply reciprocating, still confirm what the cylinder should do after power loss. If a mid-stroke pause is required, add the permitted deviation, holding time, mounting orientation and load conditions.
Safety: before replacement, stop the machine per the equipment procedure, isolate electrical and pneumatic energy, release residual pressure, and securely support any load that could fall or move. This article explains selection principles; it is not a guide to working on a live circuit.
Read how the air flows first, then decide whether the load can be held.
Reference
Festo - valve port and position numbering. SMC - SY five-port valve operating principles. Selection and installation must follow the specific model documentation and the equipment risk assessment.
Frequently asked questions
Does a three-position valve stop the cylinder halfway?
No. A position is a valve air-path state. A three-position valve adds a centre state, but whether the cylinder stops - and whether it stays there - depends on the centre function, the load and leakage.
What is the difference between closed, exhaust and pressure centre?
Closed centre blocks the main ports, exhaust centre vents both working ports, and pressure centre supplies both. Each behaves differently with a load, and none is a guaranteed lock.
Will a closed-centre valve hold a vertical load?
Not reliably. Air is compressible and leakage is possible, so the piston can drift. A vertical load that must not move requires a separately assessed locking or mechanical solution.
Can I replace a two-position valve with a three-position one?
Not as a direct substitution. Confirm the centre function, wiring, voltage, port size and flow, and confirm what the machine must do after power or air loss.
Why does a pressure-centre valve still allow movement?
On a single-rod cylinder the effective area differs between the cap side and the rod side, so equal pressure produces unequal force. Supplying both sides does not guarantee the piston is held.
Pneumatic components
elechub.ls supplies pneumatic push-in fittings, tubing, valves, silencers and cylinders - sourced factory-direct from Liushi, China and inspected before dispatch.
- Pneumatic push-in fittings - straight, elbow, tee, Y and cross types
- Request a quotation for valves, cylinders and pneumatic components
Need a second price on pneumatic components? Send us the part numbers. Request a quote.